Will trusts vs lifetime trusts
A Will trust is written into your Will and only starts when you die, while a lifetime trust starts as soon as you set it up and fund it.
Last reviewed · Reviewed by [REVIEWER NAME, CREDENTIALS]
This guide covers the law in England and Wales only. Scotland and Northern Ireland have different rules.
This guide covers England and Wales only.
The short answer
Choose a Will trust when you want to keep control of everything in your lifetime and only set rules for what happens after you die. Choose a lifetime trust when you want something to happen now. That could be passing on cash, or making sure life cover goes to the right people.
Many families use both. They are not either-or.
Side by side
| Feature | Will trust | Lifetime trust |
|---|---|---|
| When it starts | On your death, from your estate | As soon as you set it up and fund it |
| Control while you are alive | Full. You still own everything | You give up ownership of what goes in |
| Probate | Your estate goes through probate first | Trust assets are owned by trustees, not part of your estate for probate |
| Care fees | Starts on death, so not deliberate deprivation | A lifetime gift can be treated as deliberate deprivation. No seven-year rule |
| Running costs | None until you die | From day one: records, HMRC registration, possibly tax returns |
| Typical cost | Part of the cost of a Will | From £795 for our trusts |
Will trusts
A Will trust is written into your Will. Nothing changes while you are alive. On your death, your executors deal with your estate, then hand the trust assets to your trustees.
Because you keep everything until death, you can change a Will trust at any time by updating your Will. Will trusts are also excluded from the Trust Registration Service for the first two years after death.
The main limit is that a Will trust does nothing while you are alive. It cannot pass money on early or use the 7-year rule. Read more in our Will trusts guide.
Lifetime trusts
A lifetime trust is set up while you are alive. You move money or a policy into it, and trustees take over.
This can do things a Will cannot. A gift into our 7-Year Trust falls outside your estate after seven years. Our Pension and Protection Trust means life cover and death-in-service benefits are paid to trustees, not your estate.
The trade-off is that you give up control of what you put in. A trust created now must be registered with HMRC within 90 days. Gifts into most lifetime trusts are chargeable lifetime transfers, taxed at 20% above your available nil-rate band of £325,000.
Risks of relying on a Will trust
A Will trust only exists if your Will survives, is accepted and is not changed. A lifetime trust exists from the day it is signed. That difference matters more than many people realise.
What if the original Will is lost or destroyed
With a Will trust
The trust is created by your original Will. If the Will cannot be found, or someone unhappy with it destroys it, the trust may never start. A copy is not always enough. TODO-VERIFY: when a copy of a lost Will can be accepted, and when a missing Will is treated as cancelled.
With a lifetime trust
The trust exists from the day the deed is signed. Your trustees hold the deed and the assets, and the trust is registered with HMRC. Losing a Will does not undo it.
What if someone disputes your Will
With a Will trust
After your death, a relative may challenge your Will. They might say you were pressured or not thinking clearly. A dispute can delay the trust or change what it receives. TODO-VERIFY: the grounds and time limits for challenging a Will in England and Wales.
With a lifetime trust
Assets already in a lifetime trust do not pass under your Will, so a dispute about the Will is less likely to affect them. TODO-VERIFY: when a claim against an estate can reach gifts made during life.
What if your Will is changed later
With a Will trust
A Will can be rewritten at any time. Pressure from a new partner late in life could lead to a new Will without the trust. Marriage can also affect an existing Will. TODO-VERIFY: the effect of marriage on an existing Will in England and Wales.
With a lifetime trust
Assets in a lifetime trust are no longer yours to redirect. That is why the decision needs care, but it also means the plan cannot be quietly undone.
What if you lose mental capacity
With a Will trust
If you can no longer make a valid Will, your current Will stays as it is. It cannot be updated, even if your family's needs change.
With a lifetime trust
Your trustees are already in place. With a discretionary trust, they can respond to changes in the family, guided by your letter of wishes.
What if your trustees never get to ask you
With a Will trust
Your trustees only take over after your death. They cannot ask what you meant, so they rely on the wording of the Will and your letter of wishes.
With a lifetime trust
Your trustees start while you are alive. You can explain your wishes in person, and they learn how you think before they ever have to act alone.
What if your estate takes months to sort out
With a Will trust
Nothing reaches a Will trust until your executors have dealt with your estate. That usually means waiting for probate first.
With a lifetime trust
The trust is already running. Payouts from policies written into a trust go straight to the trustees, usually within weeks.
None of this makes a Will trust a bad choice. It costs less, keeps you in control and suits many families. A lifetime trust only protects what you put into it, and you give up control of those assets. For many people the answer is both: a Will for the home and the rest of the estate, and a lifetime trust for money they can spare or for policy payouts.
Things to consider
- Care fees. No trust is a guaranteed way to avoid care fees. Be cautious of anyone who says otherwise. Our guide to lifetime property trusts explains why.
- Your home. The residence nil-rate band, up to £175,000, only applies to a home left on death to direct descendants. It cannot be used for lifetime gifts into a discretionary trust.
- The settlor cannot benefit. For a lifetime gift to work for inheritance tax, you must be excluded from benefiting.
- Running costs. Trust income over £500 a year is taxed. In a discretionary trust it is 45% on most income and 39.35% on dividends.
When each one is the wrong choice
A Will trust is the wrong choice if you want money to leave your estate now. It also cannot pay out life cover without waiting for probate.
A lifetime trust is the wrong choice if you might need the money back. It may also not be worth the cost if your estate is unlikely to pay inheritance tax.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Will trust cheaper than a lifetime trust?
Usually yes. A Will trust is written as part of your Will and has no running costs while you are alive. A lifetime trust has set-up costs and needs running from day one.
Can I have both?
Yes. Many families have a Will with a trust in it, and a separate lifetime trust for life cover, a pension or a cash gift.
Does a Will trust avoid probate?
No. Your estate goes through probate first. The trust is then set up from the estate. Assets already in a lifetime trust are owned by the trustees, not you.
Which is better for care fees?
Neither can promise protection. A Will trust starts on death, so it is not deliberate deprivation. A lifetime gift can be treated as deliberate deprivation, and there is no seven-year rule for care fees.
Can I change a Will trust?
Yes, while you are alive, by updating your Will. A lifetime trust is usually much harder to change once it is set up.